Back to Plano

Plano ISD lost 427 students to vouchers, third most in North Texas, nonprofit analysis finds

The departures could cost the district about $3.5 million in state funding, an estimate by two education nonprofits says. Voucher supporters say the program uses separate money and takes nothing from public schools.

Demarcus Ferris

October 16, 20262 min read

Plano school funding - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Plano ISD lost 427 students to the state's new voucher program this school year, the third-largest number among North Texas districts, according to an analysis released this week by two education nonprofits and published by The Dallas Morning News.

The Texas Center for Voucher Transparency and Every Texan estimate those departures could cost Plano ISD about $3.5 million in state funding. Only Dallas ISD, with 807 students and an estimated $6.6 million, and Fort Worth ISD, with 576 students and $4.7 million, ranked higher in the region.

The 427 students equal about 0.92% of Plano ISD's enrollment of 46,612, according to the district-by-district table that accompanies the News' report.

How the estimate works

The groups filed public records requests for the number of former public school students leaving each district through the Texas Education Freedom Accounts program. The News said it verified the figures, a snapshot of students who had left by Aug. 10, with the state comptroller's office.

Every Texan puts the loss at $8,198.69 in state funding for each departing student, based on statewide weighted daily attendance from the 2023-24 school year. The News noted that actual per-student losses vary by district. Texas districts are funded largely on attendance, so fewer students generally means less state money.

Across North Texas, the analysis counts at least 8,300 students who left more than 50 districts, for an estimated $68.8 million.

Nearby districts

The same table lists these estimates for Plano's neighbors:

  • Richardson ISD: 287 students, about $2.35 million
  • Frisco ISD: 259 students, about $2.12 million
  • McKinney ISD: 193 students, about $1.58 million
  • Allen ISD: 127 students, about $1.04 million

The other side

Supporters of the program dispute the idea of a loss. Nathan Cunneen, Texas state director of the American Federation for Children, told the News the program "does not 'take' or utilize a single dollar of public-school funds," because the Legislature set aside a separate pot of money for it.

The accounts give families $10,474 for private school, $2,000 for homeschooling and up to $30,000 for students with disabilities. The program's first year cost about $1 billion, and the comptroller's office has asked lawmakers for another $2.3 billion to expand it in the next two-year budget when the Legislature meets in January.

The News' report did not include comment from Plano ISD.

Sources

The Dallas Morning News

datawrapper.dwcdn.net

Share

Demarcus Ferris

Demarcus Ferris writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Plano.

Related Stories

More in Texas