The Dallas Cowboys are approaching a critical decision regarding their backup quarterback position as the 2026 roster cutdown day nears. With Dak Prescott firmly established as the starter, the team must decide between Joe Milton III and Sam Howell, both of whom have made strong cases for inclusion in the final roster.
This summer, the Cowboys have focused on developing a new defensive identity under defensive coordinator Christian Parker, implementing a 3-4 scheme. The preseason has served as a testing ground for this revamped defense, as well as for evaluating the backup quarterbacks. Both Milton and Howell have showcased their skills, but the team can only keep one without sacrificing depth elsewhere on the roster.
Milton brings a high-risk, high-reward style of play, characterized by impressive arm talent and athleticism. He has demonstrated the ability to escape pressure and make plays outside the structure of the offense, which has caught the attention of the coaching staff. In contrast, Howell offers valuable experience, having already played in regular-season games and navigated the complexities of NFL defenses.
His familiarity with game situations could make him a safer option if Prescott were to miss time.
The Cowboys face a challenging decision: keep both quarterbacks, which would mean carrying three on the active roster, or make a sacrifice in another position. The presence of a third quarterback could limit the team's ability to fill other crucial roles, such as defensive linemen or special teams contributors, who are essential for weekly game contributions.
Retaining both Milton and Howell would protect against the risk of losing either player to waivers, as both possess attributes that could be appealing to other teams. However, the Cowboys must weigh the benefits of having a backup with upside against the need for depth in other areas of the roster.
